Is there a bug?

Created at 21 Jan 2025, 11:18
How’s your experience with the cTrader Platform?
Your feedback is crucial to cTrader's development. Please take a few seconds to share your opinion and help us improve your trading experience. Thanks!
RO

rosscortb

Joined 04.09.2024

Is there a bug?
21 Jan 2025, 11:18


Hello,

 

I have been doing some optimization and have raised the difference between the optimization results and back testing with Click Algo who are suggesting that there might be a bug in the system

I ran an optimization for Aiden Super Trend Cbot: 

 US500 with IC Markets, Fixed 5 with M1 Bars. Period 01/01/2024 - 30/12/2024

 

 

Backtesting same period -
Open 3 trades in Dec only

 

 

 

Why would results differ so much with only 3 trades been opened all within 17  days of each other?

Thanks

 

Ross

 


@rosscortb
Replies

firemyst
24 Jan 2025, 00:50

Why would results differ so much with only 3 trades been opened all within 17  days of each other?

One possibility is because of the market moves within those 17 days? That's how the markets work :-)

 

I'm not sure how you expect anyone to help you when you haven't described the strategy, shown any code, why you're using one-minute bar data as opposed to tick-data doing your testing, what time frame the bot is running under, the trade entries/exits on the back test with and without the optimized parameters, etc etc.

 

For instance, the bot could make decisions on every tick, but by running on one-minute bars you only get the bar data, not every tick.

Within bars they could be huge spikes not captured in bar data but would be with tick data.


@firemyst