Differents values from RSI indicators in two different robots

Created at 28 Nov 2021, 01:08

Joined 11.03.2019

Differents values from RSI indicators in two different robots
28 Nov 2021, 01:08

I have a robot the write same data to file that i use for AI training, and i have a different robot that use the same indicators to comunicate with a WebService to get a prediction from AI.

Many data are the same like open, close, high, low, MovingAvarage and many others but RSI and BollingerBands are not the same, some decimal numbers are different...

For example:

this are RSI from the 2 differents robot and the difference

RSI one RSI two difference

34,346564   34,309287   0,037277
36,156472   36,123631   0,032841
35,216511   35,18139   0,035121
35,168786   35,133548   0,035238
36,524863   36,492901   0,031962
34,721973   34,685809   0,036164
34,988265   34,952583   0,035682
34,529831   34,493502   0,036329
34,125175   34,088511   0,036664
33,267478   33,230163   0,037315
36,006483   35,973282   0,033201
34,637252   34,601015   0,036237
33,218823   33,181474   0,037349
33,743925   33,706961   0,036964
33,941592   33,904782   0,03681
36,193877   36,161365   0,032512
36,617144   36,585633   0,031511
39,444082   39,419023   0,025059
37,678542   37,651624   0,026918
39,376986   39,351852   0,025134

this is the first robot

using cAlgo.API;
using cAlgo.API.Indicators;
using cAlgo.API.Internals;
using System.IO;
using System.Text.RegularExpressions;

namespace cAlgo.Robots
{
[Robot(TimeZone = TimeZones.UTC, AccessRights = AccessRights.Internet | AccessRights.FileSystem)]
public class SaveData2 : Robot
{
[Parameter("Source")]
public DataSeries Source { get; set; }

[Parameter("TimeFrame1")]
public TimeFrame tFrame { get; set; }

[Parameter("TimeFrame2")]
public TimeFrame tFrame2 { get; set; }

[Parameter("TimeFrame3")]
public TimeFrame tFrame3 { get; set; }

private StreamWriter output;
MovingAverage S_Slow;
MovingAverage S_Slow2;
MovingAverage S_Fast;
RelativeStrengthIndex S_RSI;
RelativeStrengthIndex S_RSI2;
MovingAverage S2_Slow;
MovingAverage S2_Slow2;
MovingAverage S2_Fast;
RelativeStrengthIndex S2_RSI;
RelativeStrengthIndex S2_RSI2;
MovingAverage S3_Slow;
MovingAverage S3_Slow2;
MovingAverage S3_Fast;
RelativeStrengthIndex S3_RSI;
RelativeStrengthIndex S3_RSI2;
BollingerBands S_BAND;
BollingerBands S2_BAND;
BollingerBands S3_BAND;
StochasticOscillator S_STO;
StochasticOscillator S2_STO;
StochasticOscillator S3_STO;
AverageDirectionalMovementIndexRating S_ADX;
AverageDirectionalMovementIndexRating S2_ADX;
protected override void OnStart()
{

S_Slow = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame).ClosePrices, 15, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S_Slow2 = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame).ClosePrices, 10, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S_Fast = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame).ClosePrices, 5, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S_RSI = Indicators.RelativeStrengthIndex(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame).ClosePrices, 14);
S_RSI2 = Indicators.RelativeStrengthIndex(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame).ClosePrices, 7);

S2_Slow = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame2).ClosePrices, 15, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S2_Slow2 = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame2).ClosePrices, 10, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S2_Fast = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame2).ClosePrices, 5, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S2_RSI = Indicators.RelativeStrengthIndex(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame2).ClosePrices, 14);
S2_RSI2 = Indicators.RelativeStrengthIndex(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame2).ClosePrices, 7);

S3_Slow = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame3).ClosePrices, 15, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S3_Slow2 = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame3).ClosePrices, 10, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S3_Fast = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame3).ClosePrices, 5, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S3_RSI = Indicators.RelativeStrengthIndex(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame3).ClosePrices, 14);
S3_RSI2 = Indicators.RelativeStrengthIndex(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame3).ClosePrices, 7);
/*
S_BAND = Indicators.BollingerBands(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame).ClosePrices, 20, 2, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S2_BAND = Indicators.BollingerBands(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame2).ClosePrices, 20, 2, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S3_BAND = Indicators.BollingerBands(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame3).ClosePrices, 20, 2, MovingAverageType.Simple);
*/
S_BAND = Indicators.BollingerBands(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame).ClosePrices, 12, 2, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S2_BAND = Indicators.BollingerBands(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame2).ClosePrices, 12, 2, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S3_BAND = Indicators.BollingerBands(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame3).ClosePrices, 12, 2, MovingAverageType.Simple);

S_ADX = Indicators.AverageDirectionalMovementIndexRating(20);
S2_ADX = Indicators.AverageDirectionalMovementIndexRating(9);
S_STO = Indicators.StochasticOscillator(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame), 9, 3, 9, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S2_STO = Indicators.StochasticOscillator(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame2), 9, 3, 9, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S3_STO = Indicators.StochasticOscillator(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame3), 9, 3, 9, MovingAverageType.Simple);
output = new StreamWriter("c:\\marketdata\\" + Symbol.Name + "-m60-360-720.txt");
//"-m60-360-720.txt");
string head = "date\tn_open\tn_close\tn_low\tn_high\tn_volume\t";
head += "open\tclose\tlow\thigh\tvolume\t";
head += "M1\tM2\tM3\tRSI1\tRSI2\tM21\tM22\tM23\tRSI21\tRSI22\tM31\tM32\tM33\tRSI31\tRSI32\tBB\tBT\tB2B\tB2T\tB3B\tB3T\t";
head += "STD1\tSTK1\tSTD2\tSTK2\tSTD3\tSTK3\t";
head += "ADX1\tADXR1\tADXM1\tADXP1";
output.WriteLine(head);
}

protected override void OnTick()
{
// Put your core logic here
}

protected override void OnStop()
{
output.Close();
// Put your deinitialization logic here
}

string buf = "";
string buf2 = "";
protected override void OnBar()
{
Bar b = Bars[Bars.Count - 2];
string temp = string.Format("\t{0:F6}\t{1:F6}\t{2:F6}\t{3:F6}\t{4}", b.Open, b.Close, b.Low, b.High, b.TickVolume);
buf2 = "";
buf2 += string.Format("\t{0:F6}\t{1:F6}\t{2:F6}\t{3:F6}\t{4:F6}", S_Slow.Result.LastValue, S_Slow2.Result.LastValue, S_Fast.Result.LastValue, S_RSI.Result.LastValue, S_RSI2.Result.LastValue);
buf2 += string.Format("\t{0:F6}\t{1:F6}\t{2:F6}\t{3:F6}\t{4:F6}", S2_Slow.Result.LastValue, S2_Slow2.Result.LastValue, S2_Fast.Result.LastValue, S2_RSI.Result.LastValue, S2_RSI2.Result.LastValue);
buf2 += string.Format("\t{0:F6}\t{1:F6}\t{2:F6}\t{3:F6}\t{4:F6}", S3_Slow.Result.LastValue, S3_Slow2.Result.LastValue, S3_Fast.Result.LastValue, S3_RSI.Result.LastValue, S3_RSI2.Result.LastValue);
buf2 += string.Format("\t{0:F6}\t{1:F6}\t{2:F6}\t{3:F6}\t{4:F6}\t{5:F6}", S_BAND.Bottom.LastValue, S_BAND.Top.LastValue, S2_BAND.Bottom.LastValue, S2_BAND.Top.LastValue, S3_BAND.Bottom.LastValue, S3_BAND.Top.LastValue);
buf2 += string.Format("\t{0:F2}\t{1:F2}\t{2:F2}\t{3:F2}\t{4:F2}\t{5:F2}", S_STO.PercentD.LastValue, S_STO.PercentK.LastValue, S2_STO.PercentD.LastValue, S2_STO.PercentK.LastValue, S3_STO.PercentD.LastValue, S3_STO.PercentK.LastValue);
buf2 += string.Format("\t{0:F6}\t{1:F6}\t{2:F6}\t{3:F6}", S_ADX.ADX.LastValue, S_ADX.ADXR.LastValue, S_ADX.DIMinus.LastValue, S_ADX.DIPlus.LastValue);

if (buf != "")
{
Regex r = new Regex("^(\t([0-9]*)(,?)([0-9]*))+$");
if (r.IsMatch(buf))
output.WriteLine(string.Format("{0}{1}{2}", b.OpenTime, temp, buf));
}
buf = temp + buf2;
}
}
}

this is the second one

using System;
using cAlgo.API;
using cAlgo.API.Indicators;
using cAlgo.API.Internals;
using System.IO;
using System.Net.Http;
using System.Collections.Generic;
using System.Threading.Tasks;

namespace cAlgo.Robots
{
[Robot(TimeZone = TimeZones.UTC, AccessRights = AccessRights.Internet | AccessRights.FileSystem)]
public class pass9 : Robot
{
[Parameter("Source")]
public DataSeries Source { get; set; }

[Parameter("TimeFrame1")]
public TimeFrame tFrame { get; set; }

[Parameter("TimeFrame2")]
public TimeFrame tFrame2 { get; set; }

[Parameter("TimeFrame3")]
public TimeFrame tFrame3 { get; set; }

[Parameter("StopLoss")]
public Double mStopLoss { get; set; }

[Parameter("TakeProfit")]
public Double mTakeProfit { get; set; }

[Parameter("Lots")]
public Double mLots { get; set; }

/*
MovingAverage UK;
MovingAverage US;
MovingAverage DE;
MovingAverage FR;
MovingAverage IT;
MovingAverage GOLD;
MovingAverage OIL;
RelativeStrengthIndex UK_RSI;
RelativeStrengthIndex US_RSI;
RelativeStrengthIndex DE_RSI;
RelativeStrengthIndex FR_RSI;
RelativeStrengthIndex IT_RSI;
RelativeStrengthIndex GOLD_RSI;
RelativeStrengthIndex OIL_RSI;
ChaikinVolatility vol;
*/
MovingAverage S_Slow;
MovingAverage S_Slow2;
MovingAverage S_Fast;
RelativeStrengthIndex S_RSI;
RelativeStrengthIndex S_RSI2;
MovingAverage S2_Slow;
MovingAverage S2_Slow2;
MovingAverage S2_Fast;
RelativeStrengthIndex S2_RSI;
RelativeStrengthIndex S2_RSI2;
MovingAverage S3_Slow;
MovingAverage S3_Slow2;
MovingAverage S3_Fast;
RelativeStrengthIndex S3_RSI;
RelativeStrengthIndex S3_RSI2;
BollingerBands S_BAND;
BollingerBands S2_BAND;
BollingerBands S3_BAND;
StochasticOscillator S_STO;
StochasticOscillator S2_STO;
StochasticOscillator S3_STO;
AverageDirectionalMovementIndexRating S_ADX;
AverageDirectionalMovementIndexRating S2_ADX;
StreamWriter log;

protected override void OnStart()
{
/*
UK = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(TimeFrame.Daily, "UK100").ClosePrices, 14, MovingAverageType.Simple);
US = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(TimeFrame.Daily, "US500").ClosePrices, 14, MovingAverageType.Simple);
DE = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(TimeFrame.Daily, "DE30").ClosePrices, 14, MovingAverageType.Simple);
FR = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(TimeFrame.Daily, "F40").ClosePrices, 14, MovingAverageType.Simple);
IT = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(TimeFrame.Daily, "IT40").ClosePrices, 14, MovingAverageType.Simple);
GOLD = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(TimeFrame.Daily, "XAUUSD").ClosePrices, 14, MovingAverageType.Simple);
OIL = Indicators.MovingAverage(MarketData.GetBars(TimeFrame.Daily, "XBRUSD").ClosePrices, 14, MovingAverageType.Simple);
*/

/*
S_BAND = Indicators.BollingerBands(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame).ClosePrices, 20, 2, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S2_BAND = Indicators.BollingerBands(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame2).ClosePrices, 20, 2, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S3_BAND = Indicators.BollingerBands(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame3).ClosePrices, 20, 2, MovingAverageType.Simple);
*/
S_BAND = Indicators.BollingerBands(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame).ClosePrices, 12, 2, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S2_BAND = Indicators.BollingerBands(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame2).ClosePrices, 12, 2, MovingAverageType.Simple);
S3_BAND = Indicators.BollingerBands(MarketData.GetBars(tFrame3).ClosePrices, 12, 2, MovingAverageType.Simple);

header = "date\tn_open\tvolume\thigh\tlow\topen\tclose\t";
header += "M1\tM2\tM3\tRSI1\tRSI2\tM21\tM22\tM23\tRSI21\tRSI22\tM31\tM32\tM33\tRSI31\tRSI32\tBB\tBT\tB2B\tB2T\tB3B\tB3T\t";
header += "STD1\tSTK1\tSTD2\tSTK2\tSTD3\tSTK3\t";
header += "ADX1\tADXR1\tADXM1\tADXP1\n";
}

protected override void OnTick()
{
// Put your core logic here
}

protected override void OnStop()
{
log.Close();
}

protected int lookback = 6;
protected int maxTimeFrame = 6;
protected int otherBars = 24 * 3;
protected string[] history;
protected int hpos = 0;
protected int hcount = 0;
protected int hlen;
string header = "";
int bars = 0;

protected override void OnBar()
{

Bar b = Bars[Bars.Count - 1];
Bar bm1 = Bars[Bars.Count - 2];
string buf = "";

buf += string.Format("{0}\t{1:F6}\t{2:F6}\t{3:F6}\t{4:F6}\t{5:F6}\t{6:F6}", b.OpenTime, b.Open, bm1.TickVolume, bm1.High, bm1.Low, bm1.Open, bm1.Close);
buf += string.Format("\t{0:F6}\t{1:F6}\t{2:F6}\t{3:F6}\t{4:F6}", S_Slow.Result.LastValue, S_Slow2.Result.LastValue, S_Fast.Result.LastValue, S_RSI.Result.LastValue, S_RSI2.Result.LastValue);
buf += string.Format("\t{0:F6}\t{1:F6}\t{2:F6}\t{3:F6}\t{4:F6}", S2_Slow.Result.LastValue, S2_Slow2.Result.LastValue, S2_Fast.Result.LastValue, S2_RSI.Result.LastValue, S2_RSI2.Result.LastValue);
buf += string.Format("\t{0:F6}\t{1:F6}\t{2:F6}\t{3:F6}\t{4:F6}", S3_Slow.Result.LastValue, S3_Slow2.Result.LastValue, S3_Fast.Result.LastValue, S3_RSI.Result.LastValue, S3_RSI2.Result.LastValue);
buf += string.Format("\t{0:F6}\t{1:F6}\t{2:F6}\t{3:F6}\t{4:F6}\t{5:F6}", S_BAND.Bottom.LastValue, S_BAND.Top.LastValue, S2_BAND.Bottom.LastValue, S2_BAND.Top.LastValue, S3_BAND.Bottom.LastValue, S3_BAND.Top.LastValue);
buf += string.Format("\t{0:F2}\t{1:F2}\t{2:F2}\t{3:F2}\t{4:F2}\t{5:F2}", S_STO.PercentD.LastValue, S_STO.PercentK.LastValue, S2_STO.PercentD.LastValue, S2_STO.PercentK.LastValue, S3_STO.PercentD.LastValue, S3_STO.PercentK.LastValue);
buf += string.Format("\t{0:F6}\t{1:F6}\t{2:F6}\t{3:F6}\n", S_ADX.ADX.LastValue, S_ADX.ADXR.LastValue, S_ADX.DIMinus.LastValue, S_ADX.DIPlus.LastValue);
history[hpos] = buf;

hpos = (hpos + 1) % hlen;

if (hcount < hlen)
{
hcount++;
return;
}

foreach (var p in Positions)
{
var span = b.OpenTime - p.EntryTime;
// Print(span.TotalMinutes);
if (span.TotalMinutes > 60 * 4 - 10)
p.Close();
}

string csv = header;
for (int i = 0; i < hlen; i++)
csv += history[(hpos + i) % hlen];

bars++;
if(bars>350)
{
log.WriteLine(csv);
log.Close();
throw new Exception("pippo");

}

var values = new Dictionary<string, string>
{
{
"csv",
csv
}
};
HttpClient client = new HttpClient();
HttpContent content = new FormUrlEncodedContent(values);
Task<HttpResponseMessage> response = Task.Run(async() => await client.PostAsync("http://localhost:5000/eurusd", content));
string res = Task.Run(async() => await response.Result.Content.ReadAsStringAsync()).Result;
content.Dispose();
response.Dispose();
client.Dispose();

var results = res.Split(',');
var pips = 1;
var pred = results[0];
// Print(pred);
if (pred == "cutted")
return;
//string text = "";
double amount = mLots * 100000;
// amount = Symbol.QuantityToVolumeInUnits((int)(Account.Balance * 250 / 100000));

if (amount > 10000000)
amount = 10000000;
//Print(amount);
//text += string.Format("{0} amount {1} ", pred, amount);

if (pred == "sell" && b.Open<bm1.High)
{
var price = b.Open;
var result = ExecuteMarketRangeOrder(TradeType.Sell, Symbol.Name, amount, pips, b.Open, "pass7");
if (result.IsSuccessful)
{
result.Position.ModifyTakeProfitPrice(b.Open - mTakeProfit * Symbol.PipSize);
double stopLoss = bm1.High;
if (stopLoss > b.Open + mStopLoss * Symbol.PipSize)
stopLoss = b.Open + mStopLoss * Symbol.PipSize;
result.Position.ModifyStopLossPrice(stopLoss);
}

}

if (pred == "buy" && b.Open>bm1.Low)
{
var price = b.Open;
var result = ExecuteMarketRangeOrder(TradeType.Buy, Symbol.Name, amount, pips, b.Open, "pass7");
if (result.IsSuccessful)
{
result.Position.ModifyTakeProfitPrice(b.Open + mTakeProfit * Symbol.PipSize);
double stopLoss = bm1.Low;
if (stopLoss < b.Open - mStopLoss * Symbol.PipSize)
stopLoss = b.Open - mStopLoss * Symbol.PipSize;
result.Position.ModifyStopLossPrice(stopLoss);
}
}

//log.WriteLine(text);
//log.Flush();
}
}
}

can you help me to understand why the indicators give different numbers?

seems that some indicators have memory of old history over the indicator period..... the problem seems to be that i use the 2 robot with different start datetime for testing.... savedata start from 2014 but pass9 start in 2021

best regards

amerigo

@astevani

Replies

amusleh
29 Nov 2021, 08:59

Hi,

Please try to use your indicator and cBot only on a single current chart time frame and then check the data, it might be due to data difference when you are loading multiple time frames data.

Or it can also be caused by double type precision issue, try to round and change the type to decimal if you want to use the same exact data.

@amusleh

Copyright © 2024 Spotware Systems Ltd. All rights reserved.
The services provided by Spotware Systems Ltd. are not available to citizens or residents of the USA. Neither is the information on our websites directed toward soliciting citizens or residents of the USA.