Cbot placed trade when deleted from automate

Created at 27 Sep 2019, 16:12
How’s your experience with the cTrader Platform?
Your feedback is crucial to cTrader's development. Please take a few seconds to share your opinion and help us improve your trading experience. Thanks!
GE

geoffgeoff

Joined 25.09.2019

Cbot placed trade when deleted from automate
27 Sep 2019, 16:12


I have recently had a cbot built and just started live trading with it.

I had found a new issue occur with it so deleted all instances and the cbot from my ctrader account yet some 18 hours later the cbot placed 2 trades?

1. The instances had been deleted

2. The cbot had been deleted (around 18 hours earlier)

3. There had never been an issue with teh cbot related to setting orders 18 hours in advance

Does anyone know how this could have happened? 

Many thanks 

Regards

Geoff


@geoffgeoff
Replies

PanagiotisCharalampous
27 Sep 2019, 16:33

Hi Geoff,

Thanks for posting in our forum. What you describe sounds very weird. 

  1. Are 100% sure there was no instance of the cBot running on any open instance of cTrader on any machine e.g. a forgotten running instance on a cTrader chart? 
  2. Can you reproduce this issue or did this happen just once?
  3. Is there any chance somebody has access to your cTrader credentials?
  4. Did you contact your broker about this? The broker can tell you from which IP and which channel did the order originate so that you can identify from which computer the order came. 
  5. Do you remember the exact steps you followed after stopping the cBot?

Best Regards,

Panagiotis

 


@PanagiotisCharalampous

geoffgeoff
27 Sep 2019, 16:46

Thanks for your reply.

My broker Icmarkets have no interest in helping and only advised to contact spotware. (I have since withdrawn my funds from them)

Spotware said that I need to request help from this forum... Again I feel poor support.

Anyway.. I did have a trade running from the previous day generated by the cbot.

That trade was a different currency pair to the two trades generated and I had also ammended that trade with new stop losses etc taking any action from the cbot out of the equation I thought.

I had previously deleted all instances and then the cbot from three areas.

1. Icmarkets

2. a second broker account

3. a VPS that Icmarkets recommended

All three areas had been deleted one after the other.

I also check to confirm they had been deleted several times prior to when the cbot normally triggered.

I'm sure this is a basic error by me I just dont know what that was and I dont want it to happen again. 

Thanks again for you help.

Geoff


@geoffgeoff

PanagiotisCharalampous
27 Sep 2019, 16:59

Hi Geoff,

Please note that Spotware does not offer official support to traders since you are not our direct clients and we do not have access to trading execution information. Investigating execution issues is a sole responsibility of the broker with whom you have a business relationship. If your broker cannot give you an answer to what happened, they can always contact our support department and authorize them to investigate further. Nevertheless, we are always open to help traders via this forum however in this case we do not have enough information to determine what caused this issue. It could have been anything e.g. accidentally starting the cBot. If you manage to reproduce this behavior again, please feel free to let us know.

Best Regards,

Panagiotis


@PanagiotisCharalampous

geoffgeoff
27 Sep 2019, 17:24

Thanks

I've recontacted icmarkets and all i can say is that they have confirmed it was the cbot that triggered the two trades. but again thats the end of their support.

Thanks for your help to date and lets see if they will actually put more effort into supprting their clients.

Cheers


@geoffgeoff

mparama
28 Sep 2019, 21:32

Did you delete/stop the cBot from VPS ?


@mparama

geoffgeoff
30 Sep 2019, 15:29

RE:

mparama said:

Did you delete/stop the cBot from VPS ?

Hi luigi,

Yes i deleted the instances and the the the cbot itself leaving no cbots at all.

I did this on the VPS and also my home computer.

I also rechecked several times leading into when the cbot is set to work and there was nothing in either account in the automate area.

Maybe I also need to delete it fro somewhere else?.

 


@geoffgeoff